As an avid reader, I almost always approach a screen adaptation with a little skepticism. The question inevitably creeps in: Will it live up to the book?

This past weekend, Karen Shayne and I did something we don’t often give ourselves permission to do — we carved out time to simply slow down and enjoy ourselves. We gathered our favorite snacks, settled onto the couch, and binge-watched Peacock’s adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand’s The Five-Star Weekend, starring Jennifer Garner as food blogger Hollis Shaw, alongside Chloë Sevigny and Regina Hall as two of the friends who shape her story.

[IMAGE — alt text: “Jennifer Garner as Hollis Shaw in Peacock’s The Five-Star Weekend”]

Somewhere along the way, we decided to toss a handful of M&M’s into our warm popcorn. The heat softened the chocolate just enough to make every handful a little indulgent. Decadent? Absolutely. A little messy? Definitely. But completely worth it.

By the time the opening scenes began, we knew we were in for more than just another television series.

If you’ve read Elin Hilderbrand’s bestselling novel, you’ll notice Peacock takes a few creative liberties with the story. Some characters are expanded, a few plotlines shift, and certain moments unfold differently than they do in the book.

It’s tempting to pause the series to reflect on a particular scene, flip back through the book, or question some of the creative liberties the writers took. But I’d encourage you not to. Instead, let the story unfold on its own. Appreciate it as an adaptation rather than a page-by-page recreation, and allow yourself to become immersed in the relationships, the emotions, and the conversations it inspires.

Because that’s where this series truly shines — and where Jennifer Garner’s performance really carries it.

At its heart, The Five-Star Weekend isn’t really about a beautiful weekend on Nantucket.

It’s about grief.

It’s about forgiveness.

It’s about second chances.

It’s about friendship.

And it’s about realizing that the women who knew us during different seasons of our lives often help us understand who we are today.

The premise is beautifully simple. After experiencing an unimaginable loss, food influencer Hollis Shaw invites four women from different chapters of her life to spend a weekend together — one from childhood, one from college, one from her career, and one from her life as an adult. Each friendship represents a different version of herself.

What begins as a reunion quickly becomes something much deeper.

[IMAGE — alt text: “Cast of The Five-Star Weekend on the Peacock series set in Nantucket”]

Old wounds surface.

Misunderstandings are confronted.

Relationships are tested.

Truths are revealed.

And healing quietly begins.

As Becky and I watched, we found ourselves doing exactly what I suspect the writers hoped we would do — not talking only about the characters, but reflecting on our own lives.

Who were the women who shaped us?

Who believed in us before we believed in ourselves?

Who sat beside us during heartbreak?

Who celebrated our biggest victories?

Who quietly disappeared because life simply became busy?

The older I get, the more I realize friendships don’t usually end because love disappears. More often, life simply gets louder. Careers demand our attention. Families grow. Children leave home. Aging parents need us. We move. We change.

And before we know it, years have passed since we’ve sat across the table from someone who once knew us better than anyone.

That’s why this story feels so meaningful.

It reminds us that every friendship has value, even if it’s connected to a different season of life.

It also gently reminds us that every person is carrying something we may never fully understand. Grief doesn’t follow a timeline. Families are complicated. Relationships are imperfect. Forgiveness is rarely easy.

Yet healing often begins with one simple decision — to show up.

The next morning, I found myself thinking about the series again. Not because I was replaying the storyline, but because I was thinking about the women who have come in and out of my own life — the friendships that have lasted for decades and the ones that quietly faded as life became busier.

That’s what I appreciated most about The Five-Star Weekend. It wasn’t just entertaining. It made me think.

And maybe that’s the best compliment I can give any book or television series.

So here’s my suggestion. Invite a few of your closest girlfriends over, make a bowl of warm popcorn with M&M’s, pour your favorite beverage, and settle in for a binge-watch on Peacock. Don’t worry about comparing every scene to the book. Just enjoy the story for what it is.

Then, sometime afterward — whether it’s over breakfast the next morning or in a text a few days later — I hope you find yourself thinking about the women who’ve shaped your own story. They just might deserve a phone call.

After all, the best stories don’t simply entertain us — they remind us what’s most important in our own lives.

My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5)

Whether you’ve read Elin Hilderbrand’s novel or are discovering the story for the first time, Peacock’s The Five-Star Weekend — led by Jennifer Garner’s heartfelt performance — delivers a thoughtful experience that celebrates friendship, resilience, forgiveness, and the beautiful complexity of the relationships that shape our lives.

I highly recommend it. Better yet, don’t watch it alone. Invite a few of your closest girlfriends over, put out a bowl of warm popcorn with M&M’s, pour your favorite beverage, and make an evening of it. Sometimes the best stories are the ones that remind us to celebrate the people who’ve been part of our own story all along.

Looking for your next binge-worthy read? Check out more picks from our Book Club.